Quick verdict
Gears of War: E-Day is the best-reviewed Gears game in years, with a Top Critic Average of 85 on OpenCritic and 89% of critics recommending it. Steam players are cooler at 73% positive across more than 11,000 reviews. The shooting is close to unanimous praise; the story, the semi-open chapters and some missing series staples are where the arguments start.
What it is
E-Day is a third-person cover shooter and a prequel that goes back to Emergence Day, the night the Locust first surfaced on Sera. It comes from The Coalition and is published by Xbox Game Studios. It launched on October 6, 2026 for PC and Xbox Series X|S, costs $69.99 for the standard edition on Steam ($99.99 for Premium), and was part of Game Pass from launch day. The package has a five-act campaign with co-op, a 4v4 Versus suite and a reworked Horde mode called Horde Siege.
Gameplay
The combat is the headline, and almost every review says so. GamesRadar+ said the game “brings Gears back to the cutting edge of shooters,” and pointed to an adaptive cover system that lets almost any object work as protection. Shacknews (9/10) called the combat the game’s greatest achievement, praising how Marcus can now slide under obstacles, vault low walls and jump gaps without losing that heavy, planted feel. VGC singled out the Prototype Lancer and Longshot as weapons that stay rewarding late into the campaign, and noted that each enemy type, from the Bilefrog to the Flayer, demands a different approach.
Weapon and armor mods, earned from hardcases hidden around the levels, give even weaker guns a reason to stay in your loadout. Not everyone likes how they are surfaced, though. PC Gamer (77/100) disliked the map markers and all-caps prompts that point you at every collectible.
The bigger complaint is the campaign’s shape. PC Gamer described it as an exhausting firefight that outstays its welcome, with encounters that feel like light remixes of each other across a run it clocked at more than 20 hours. Most other outlets put the length at 10 to 16 hours. GameSpot (7/10) found the semi-open areas dull, and Shacknews flagged side missions that keep asking you to hold a position. VGC added that one bridge location is revisited three times.
Multiplayer earns warmer words. IGN (9/10) called the suite excellent and highlighted Horde Siege, where up to three squads fight across a large map, build defences between waves and sometimes stumble into each other’s battles. Versus covers Team Deathmatch, Conquest, Crucible and Demolition, and Shacknews picked Demolition as its favourite.
Graphics and sound
Presentation is a strength. Pure Xbox (10/10) called Kalona City a technical marvel and praised the collapsing skyscrapers and burning districts. VGC liked that the art direction breaks from the series’ grey reputation, with red-lit tunnels, moonlit forests and green hilltops. Kalona also changes as the invasion spreads, so places you walked through early return in ruins later.
On audio, Shacknews described heavy metal riffs in the fights and sombre strings around the moments of loss, and Pure Xbox said the soundtrack matches the game’s fear, anger and sadness.
Controls and performance
The new movement set is a clear upgrade. PC Gamer noted a dedicated jump and climb button, run on L3, and fewer accidental rolls into cover than in older entries. Melee is the weak spot, with GamesRadar+ calling it soft and weightless.
On Xbox Series X, Pure Xbox reported a 30fps quality mode and a 60fps performance mode that holds up well but can look soft. Two-player split-screen co-op runs at 30fps. PC is more demanding. Shacknews called the PC version very resource-hungry, and testing by Kami Labs measured roughly 45fps at 1440p on an RTX 5070 Ti at the highest preset without upscaling. Performance came up in about one in eight of the negative Steam reviews that outlet sampled.
Content and value
There is a lot here: a long campaign with co-op, four Versus modes and Horde Siege, which several critics expect to be where players spend most of their time. PC Gamer reported that the developers chose not to use a battle pass for multiplayer, although the Steam listing does show in-app purchases.
At $69.99 it is a full-price release, so Game Pass is the cheaper way in for anyone already subscribed. Some veterans also feel they are getting less of the classic toolkit. Players on Steam list the missing chainsaw duel, sticky grenades, ranked play, private matches and private Horde, and Pure Xbox also wished chainsaw duels and meat shields had returned.
Where opinions split
Critics and Steam players disagree most about the story. Critics mostly call it the weakest part of the package but still a solid frame for the action. VGC said it leans on action-movie clichés and gives the Marcus and Dom relationship too little room, while IGN rated the campaign highly. Among the negative Steam reviews Kami Labs analysed, about half centred on Mags Carter’s prominent role, with players saying they bought the game for Marcus and Dom. Others focused on missing features and PC performance.
The critic side is not unified either. Pure Xbox gave it a perfect score, while PC Gamer summed it up as “never felt better to play, or more creatively stagnant.” That line sums up the split well: few people dispute the gunplay, but plenty question whether a near-remake of the series’ roots was the right move.
Who should play it, and who should skip it
Play it if you want top-tier cover shooting, co-op with a friend on the couch or online, or a Horde mode that goes bigger than ever. It is also a reasonable starting point for newcomers, since Screen Rant called it a good entry point to the series.
Skip it, or wait for a sale, if you need a gripping story to carry a long campaign, if repeated hold-the-line objectives wear you down, or if you are on a mid-range PC and dislike leaning on upscaling. Long-time Versus players who live for chainsaw duels and ranked matches should check the patch notes first.
Final thoughts
E-Day gets the most important thing right: shooting Locust feels better than it has in years, and the reviews back that up from top to bottom. A story that divides players, a campaign that runs long and a demanding PC version keep it from classic status. For Xbox and PC shooter fans, especially on Game Pass, it is an easy recommendation; at full price, it depends on how much you care about the gunplay compared with everything else.
Strengths
- Best cover shooting in the series, per most critics
- New slide, vault and jump moves add flow
- Horde Siege expands co-op with up to three squads
- Kalona City looks spectacular as it falls apart
- Day one on Game Pass
Weaknesses
- Campaign runs long with repetitive hold-the-line objectives
- Story and character focus divide players
- Demanding on PC, relies on upscaling
- Missing classic features like chainsaw duels and ranked play



















